NuvaRing may have fewer side effects compared to other combined hormonal contraceptive methods
Researchers in Spain recruited 805 women from local family planning clinics to evaluate the side effects of the NuvaRing contraceptive vaginal ring. The women were evaluated at entry into the study, and after 3 and 6 months of NuvaRing use. Some women chose NuvaRing initially (423 women) and some switched from another hormonal method to NuvaRing (382). Of the 805 women who started the study, 74% completed the six month trial.
The women who switched from another method of hormonal contraception to NuvaRing had a significant decrease in headaches, nausea, and breast tenderness during the six month test period. Headaches decreased from 10% of women at baseline to 1.2% after 6 cycles (p<0.01), nausea dropped from 4.8% to 0.4%, and breast tenderness decreased from 6.4% at baseline to 1.7% after 6 cycles of use (p<0.05).
The steady rate of release and lower overall dose of hormones seen with NuvaRing may help explain why the women had an improvement in their symptoms. The lack of a direct comparison to an alternate form of hormonal contraception in this study prevents any conclusions about whether NuvaRing is better or worse than traditional oral contraceptives. Symptoms such as breast tenderness and nausea decrease with time with all forms of hormonal contraception.
Lete, I. Clinical experience with NuvaRing® in Spain shows that the monthly contraceptive ring is associated with a low incidence of hormone-related adverse effects
Abstracts of the 9th Congress of the European Society of Contraception
http://www.contraception-esc.com/istanbul/abstracts/P016.htm
Use of a copper IUD does not affect subsequent fertility
The use of IUDs in North America is becoming increasingly popular. Many patients are still concerned about the possibility of infertility after using an IUD. A recent prospective Norwegian study looked at copper IUD use and subsequent fertility.
A total of 957 women had a copper IUD inserted between May 1993 and April 1995 as part of a contraceptive effectiveness study. Women who had their IUD removed by June 1, 1999 were eligible to enter this study about fertility. In total, 397 women were eligible, and 205 agreed to participate. All women in the study had already delivered at least one child.
Group A included 109 women who had the IUD removed to become pregnant. Group B included 96 women whose IUD was removed due to complications (bleeding, pain, expulsion, and other medical complications) and later desired a pregnancy. The women in group B tended to be younger, and removed their IUD sooner than women in Group A.
In Group A, 102 of 109 (95.6%) of women were pregnant within 25 months. Of the 7 women who did not get pregnant, 4 had changed their mind about achieving a pregnancy and had restarted contraception and 3 were investigated for infertility. Two of the three couples had male factor infertility and the third woman had endometriosis.
In Group B, 94 of 96 women became pregnant within 24 months, and the other 2 women did not proceed to infertility workup.
The first pregnancies after IUD removal in Group A were all intrauterine, and 84 went on to a live birth. In group B, there were 92 intrauterine pregnancies (14 miscarriages) and 2 ectopic pregnancies. These rates of miscarriage and ectopic pregnancy are similar to those in the general population.
This study showed that the use of a copper IUD did not increase the risk of infertility due to tubal damage (presumably from infection or inflammation). Secondly, women who had an IUD removed due to a complication are as likely to conceive as women who did not have complications with their IUD.
These findings are consistent with findings of a large study published in 2001 that found that previous use of a copper IUD is not associated with an increased risk of tubal occlusion among nulligravid women (women who never had a baby before).
Garmo Hov Gunhild, Skjeldestada Finn Egil, Hilstad Torunn. Use of IUD and subsequent fertility — follow-up after participation in a randomized clinical trial. Contraception 75 (2007) 88– 92.
Hubacher et al. Use of copper intrauterine devices and the risk of tubal infertility among nulligravid women. N Engl J Med. 2001 Aug 23;345(8):561-7.
No increase in HIV with hormonal contraception
An international group of researchers wanted to further define the link, if any, between hormonal contraception (combined oral contraceptive pills [COC] and Depo Provera (DMPA)) and the risk of acquiring HIV. After going through the testing protocols, 6109 HIV-negative women in Thailand, Uganda, and Zimbabwe were enrolled in the study.
Of the 4439 African participants, 34.7% used COC’s, 34.2% used DMPA, and 31.1% used a non-hormonal method (eg: withdrawal, condoms). Although the majority of the women did not engage in high risk sexual behaviours (multiple partners, sex trade workers), less than half reported regular condom use. Women using hormonal methods were older, more likely to have a partner, and had an average of 2 previous pregnancies. Women using non-hormonal methods tended to have higher risk sexual behaviours, but were also more likely to use condoms. Overall, high risk behaviour was uncommon in either group.
Data were available for 92% of the women at 24 months. There were 213 new HIV infections during this time period, with an incidence rate of 2.75/100 woman-years, compared to 2.59 for the COC, 3.11 for DMPA, and 2.55 for the non-hormonal group. When other factors were accounted for (such as condom use), neither the COC nor DMPA were more likely to be associated with acquiring HIV than the non-hormone group.
The researchers also looked at women with high risk behaviours in each group. Although these subsets had a higher rate of HIV acquisition when compared to the rest of the women in the study, there was no difference between those using hormonal or non-hormonal contraception.
The information from this study is reassuring to women living in locations with high rates of HIV. They can continue to use reliable contraception methods without concern for a significant increase in the possibility of HIV infection.
Morrison CS et al; for the Hormonal Contraception and the Risk of HIV Acquisition (HC-HIV) Study Group. Hormonal contraception and the risk of HIV acquisition.
AIDS. 2007 Jan 2;21(1):85-95.